For the first part of the mission, players must simply follow Dogmeat, allowing him to lead them to the location of Nick Valentine. It can be quite the dangerous trip if you haven’t cleared a lot of the area, so keep your head on a swivel and ensure that you perform frequent quick saves to stop you from having to play long sections of the quest over again. Dogmeat should have an objective marker on him for the duration of the adventure, and if he doesn’t, you likely need to stop and search for clues.
The Follow Dogmeat objective will be interrupted several times, tasking players with finding clues that show Kellogg has been there, and that your canine companion is on the right track. After you successfully find a clue, you’ll get back to following Dogmeat further along the trail. If he stops moving, it’s a sure sign that you need to stop and have a look around. Here are the clues you’re looking for each step of the way.
While looking at the building, go to your left, hugging the building and going down a small set of stairs. This will take you to a couple burned out cars in an underground parking facility. Go down the stairs in that facility and you’ll come to a room with a dead body in a chair. Go through the door to the next room and you should see another that will lead you into Fort Hagen. It’s just to the right of the parking garage ramp.
When you enter Fort Hagen you’ll be in a stairwell, and there are floors above you, but not below you. You’ll need to clear them all of about a half dozen Synths that are roaming about, but Nick Valentine should assist you with this. Don’t worry about looting just yet, that’s better left for when there’s nothing roaming about trying to kill you. Oh, and destroy all the turrets as well - those are a pain.
Also, be careful when you are firing a loud weapon - the Synths from other floors will wander up to engage you if they hear you creating a raucous. If you have some mines, consider placing them in the doorways and stair well, then making some noise to attract the Synths to your location. You’ll likely get several of them before you have to shoot them yourself.
When everything is dead, search all the floors and rooms for anything that you can take with you. There is a terminal in the stairwell, but that just turns on the nearby robot, and that thing turned on us when we started shooting Synths. Likely best to avoid it. There is also a locked cage on the top floor, and the terminal to open that is in the center of the room on a support beam. You can command Nick Valentine to hack it if you don’t want to be fussed. You can also visit our hacking and locking picking guide if you want to get better are handing these situations yourself.
When you’re ready to move on, get into the elevator and take a trip down a few floors. This will deliver you to a bunker like basement, and in the distance will be a turret and some patrolling Synths. Take them out at your leisure, being sure not to set any traps off along the narrow corridor. When the area is clear, go into the room where the turret was posted and head down the stairs. You’ll have some more halls and alcoves to search, but eventually you’ll find yourself in the Fort Hagen Command Center.
It’s going to be more of the same for quite some time. You’ll have to deal with Synths, turrets, and even Kellogg taunting you as you get closer to your target. We aren’t going to walk you through every inch of the process, so keep clearing the command center one room at a time, making your way through the doors and halls will connect you to the man who kidnapped your son.
Tip: Shortly after passing a wheelchair in a hallway, look for some stairs and a side (boiler) room. The Fort Hagen Armory Password is down there, and you’re going to want that. The armory is just a little way ahead, to the left when you go through a door.When you get to an oval office (not the oval office), Kellogg will tell you he’s just up ahead, and that his Synths are standing down. If you haven’t already done so, backtrack and get into the armory - there are some really good things in there for your upcoming battle. When you’re ready, go through the next door to progress things forward.
Chat with Kellogg in whatever way you choose, as the end result will be the same no matter what. You have to fight him, and for this we highly suggest you bring some Molotovs. Kellogg will hide behind the desks, and throwing some bombs is a great way to dig him out without exposing yourself to danger. We even backed up out of the room, forcing him (and his Synths) into a bottleneck. Be aware, however, that Kellogg will regenerate health when he deals a critical hit. It’s the legendary perk on his gun, which of course you can add to your collection when the fight is over. Just focus on the Synths first, and then lay into Kellogg with all you have. There are no tricks to this boss fight.
You need to do something specific to complete this objective, but there are lots of great things to loot as well, such as Kellogg’s Pistol. To move things forward, grab Kellogg’s Terminal Password, as well as the Cybernetic Brain Augmenter (you’ll need that for the next mission). They can both be found on his body, and then you can move to Kellogg’s Terminal. When you read his access logs, the objective will be complete.
Easy enough. Just walk over to the Synth and have a conversation. That should take care of this one quite nicely.
You’ll have to head back to Diamond City for this part. Just make your way out of Fort Hagen by taking the elevator that is marked as an objective. This should take you to the roof, and from there you can fast travel back to the Public Occurrences office. Piper will be inside, and that’s when we decided to have her take over the companion duties from Nick Valentine. Just be sure to get any gear that you stored on Valentine before you send him off. Grab it yourself, and then give it to Piper to carry back to your base.
You can continue on with the next main mission if you’d like. That will be Fallout 4: Dangerous Minds. You can also roam the Wasteland and find new adventures to have, in which case USgamer’s Fallout 4 Walkthrough and Guide is a great place to get you rolling.