Borderlands 2 Captain Scarlett and Her Pirate's Booty Walkthrough Part 15 – Sidequests: Wurmwater (Part 4)
Just Desserts for Desert Deserters
Available from the Wurmwater Bounty Board after completing “Two Easy Pieces”. Apparently Captain Scarlett has a few deserters run off when Sandman attacked. She wants you to go and kill them for her. Head on back to the Oasis exit. Once the turn hard to the south and and get to the Southern edge of the map.
Kill Benny The Booster
Head over to the West and you will find the entrance to the Deserter's Camp. Get through the initial area with the Cursed Pirates, Swabbies and Pirates coming after you. Head on over to the left, going up the stairs and following the walkway over to the South. Head into the heights of the camp and you will find your target standing amongst the numerous pirates. He was the old cook and tried at least 7 times to poison Captain Scarlett.
Kill Deckhand
Time to head for Hayter's Folly. Leave the Canyon Deserter's Camp and turn to the Northwestern portion of the Oasis area. Once again you need to get through the pirates that are around. Once inside head for Aqua Nexus and go over to the left toward the lift. This is the fastest way to get to the area you will find Deckhand, Sandman's Lookout.
Deckhand is found in Sandman's Lookout so you would need to head all the way around the area to get to the location if you do not take the lift shortcut. Just head around to the lookout found behind where you fought Sandman and The Big Sleep. Deckhand himself is a tougher Grogmaster who will run up and start clubbing you with his bottle.
Kill Toothless Terry
Head for the Fast Travel Station and head on out to the Rustyard (failing that Wurmwater and making the trip). Once in the Rustyard you need to get through the first area to the Rusty Cog Settlement. Once inside there you need to fight your way on through to the back.
You will find Toothless Terry around the bridge that leads out to Hebert's shack. He is slow moving, massive, and carries a rocket launcher. Take advantage of the cover in the area and you should have little trouble taking him and all the other pirates down.
With all those men dead return to Wurmwater and the ship to claim your rewards.
Rewards: $674, Unique Shotgun: The Jolly Roger (always fires in a Skull and Crossbones pattern), 15780 XP