Is a dragon sq shield good

My choice here would be the granite shield because it's cheap, almost as effective for melee, and awesome range defence. if you REALLY love the strength bonus, get the obsidian, duh. dragon square is not really necessary as the price doesn't pay for the slightly extra defence stats.


Prices: granite shield=33.9k
obby shield(Toktz-ket-xil)=26.6k
dragon sq. shield=307.6k