What game is better Sonic Heroes or shadow the hedgehog

Sonic Heroes received more positive reviews than Shadow the Hedgehog. Game Rankings gave the game 69.2% for the PlayStation 2, 74.1% for the Gamecube, 74.4% for the Xbox, and 60% for the PC. Averaging the four together gives an overall review of 69.425%. Shadow the Hedgehog although, received more negative reviews including the multiple weapons, vehicles, and somewhat needless cursing. Other complaints include bad level design, unrefined controls, and a faulty camera system. On Game Rankings, the GameCube, PlayStation 2, and Xbox versions have an average ratio of 53%, 49%, and 52%, respectively, giving an overall 51.3% review, making Sonic Heroes the better game.