Is Link a tragic character
Is Link a tragic character
This may seem like an odd discussion, but it is something I have
thought about for quite a while and I feel the need to express my
thoughts on this matter. I had come across this concept a while ago
looking through a list someone posted of tragic characters in
gaming. I came across the usual candidates, Solid Snake, Roxas etc.
The entry that most baffled me though, was Link had been placed on
the list somewhere at the bottom. Coming from someone who is not a
large Zelda fan, I have played a number of Zelda titles and have
enjoyed them, I was baffled to see Link on the list. Link is
suppose to be a blank slate for the player to inhabit and have him
become their own character. but I was willing to give the benefit
of the doubt. I read the reasons he was placed and essentially it
boiled down to the idea that since Link is constantly reincarnated,
having to fight evil and witness so many terrible things that Link
is doomed to a never ending cycle of hardships. This of course does
not apply to all the games in the franchise as many of them are
sequels and continue the adventures of an already established Link,
such as how Majora's Mask is a follow up to Ocarina of Time and A
Link between Worlds is a followup to A Link to the Past. My first
thoughts were dismissive towards such a pondering, after all, I
doubt Shigeru Miyamoto or Nintendo would have wanted to imply such
an idea of Link being a figure of constant struggles, fights and
loss, especially since Miyamoto himself is quoted to always put
game-play before storytelling. Though, the more I thought about
these claims and the game series as a whole, the more I began to
believe the idea of Link being a tragic figure, keep in a mind I
said tragic figure and not tragic hero as they are very different
concepts...
- A tragic figure is a person who due to certain events is
usually lead to misfortune or suffering.
- A tragic hero in classical sense, at least according to
Aristotle's Law, is an admired and valiant person, whose hamartia
(flaw) leads to their downfall, Macbeth is a great example of
this.
Out of these two definitions, I believe tragic figure is the most
appropriate when talking about Link, unless you can think of a
tragic flaw he may possess, which I don't believe he has, unless
you could count his unwavering courage granted to him by the
Triforce. To further back up these claims it's best to imagine this
from a streamlined viewpoint. Link throughout his many lives and
adventures is forced every time he is reincarnated to leave his
home and loved ones to embark on a journey, fight evil, face
horrifying creatures and put his life at risk all for a destiny he
did not ask for. To say nothing of many of the things he has
witnessed in his many lives such as his Uncle's death in Link to
the Past, the world's destruction (which was somewhat his fault)
and missing out on his childhood in Ocarina of Time and that's not
even getting to the many terrifying experiences he must go through
in games such as Majora's Mask or Twilight Princess and I'm sure
I'm leaving out other moments from games that I've not played which
are equally frightening and sorrowful. It also becomes more
intriguing when you consider that character that inspired Link,
Peter Pan. For those of you who have never read the original Peter
Pan book, Peter himself is presented as a tragic character. A boy
who chooses to blissfully and ignorantly refuse to grow up all
while sacrificing his humanity, maturity and even his ability to
remember his most prominent moments in his life all while living
through a constant cycle of loving and losing (Peter forgets Tinker
Bell after she dies) and constantly forgetting only to experience
it all over again a rinse-and-repeat cycle. To put it bluntly,
Link's entire existence is also built on a rinse-and-repeat cycle,
that he can never escape from, even he does not remember his
experiences between certain games the fact that he has done all
this before and is destined to keep doing it is all in itself
saddening. This to me adds so much more to a character that I had
always thought was a blank-slate. At least Romeo and Juliet have an
end to their suffering, at least Macbeth has an end to his
suffering, all tragedies end, except Link. Thank you all so much
for reading and what do you think? Is Link a tragic character?
Please leave your comments (use the "discuss" link).